Filed from 4 published puzzles

FATCHANCE

Set to 4 different clues across 4 published puzzles, most often "I wouldn't bet on it!" — The New York Times, Sunday, 13 January 2002.

9 letters

Every clue on record, most used first

"I wouldn't bet on it!"once
The New York Times — Sunday, 13 January 2002
Turndown #5once
The New York Times — Sunday, 1 April 2001
Cynic's snort #3once
The New York Times — Monday, 5 February 2001
"Never!"once
The New York Times — Wednesday, 29 May 1996

Other answers to these clues

ATNOTIME8 letters
INAPIGSEYE10 letters
NOTAPRAYER10 letters
NOTONCE7 letters
NOTONYOURLIFE13 letters
NOWAYJOSE9 letters
ONNOOCCASION12 letters
WELLI5 letters
WHENHELLFREEZES15 letters
WHENPIGSFLY11 letters