GRINS

Set to 9 different clues across 9 published puzzles, most often “Makes like the Cheshire Cat” — The New York Times, Wednesday, 8 April 2009.

5 letters

Every clue on record, most used first

Makes like the Cheshire Catonce
The New York Times — Wednesday, 8 April 2009
Alfred E. Neuman visagesonce
The New York Times — Sunday, 26 October 2008
They may accompany winksonce
The New York Times — Thursday, 3 April 2003
Smug looks, sometimesonce
The New York Times — Friday, 29 March 2002
Shows satisfactiononce
The New York Times — Saturday, 4 August 2001
"Aw, shucks" expressionsonce
The New York Times — Wednesday, 1 March 2000
Beamsonce
The New York Times — Friday, 19 December 1997
Embarrassed expressions, at timesonce
The New York Times — Saturday, 20 July 1996
Silent greetingsonce
The New York Times — Saturday, 24 September 1994