TORIC

Every clue on record, most used first

• Doughnut-shaped5 times

  The New York Times — Tuesday, 5 May 2009

• Like a bagelonce

  The New York Times — Sunday, 24 April 2011

• Like some fancy soap bubblesonce

  The New York Times — Thursday, 12 November 2009

• Like most washersonce

  The New York Times — Saturday, 19 February 2005

• Like inner tubesonce

  The New York Times — Wednesday, 21 June 2000

• Like Life Saversonce

  The New York Times — Sunday, 4 July 1999

• Ring-shapedonce

  The New York Times — Sunday, 7 February 1999

• Doughnutlikeonce

  The New York Times — Sunday, 1 June 1997

• Like an inner tube, geometricallyonce

  The New York Times — Wednesday, 11 December 1996

• Shaped like an inner tubeonce

  The New York Times — Sunday, 1 January 1995