Filed from 13 published puzzles

VAMP

Set to 7 different clues across 13 published puzzles, most often “Seductress” — The New York Times, Sunday, 4 July 2010.

4 letters

Every clue on record, most used first

Seductress4 times
The New York Times — Sunday, 4 July 2010
Improvise4 times
The New York Times — Sunday, 14 October 2007
"Hard Hearted Hannah" of songonce
The New York Times — Saturday, 24 January 2004
Man trapperonce
The New York Times — Tuesday, 25 June 2002
Fill in time on stageonce
The New York Times — Wednesday, 20 September 2000
Theda Bara, e.g.once
The New York Times — Wednesday, 11 March 1998
Sirenonce
The New York Times — Sunday, 9 July 1995

Other answers to these clues

ADLIB5 letters
ALERT5 letters
ALLURER7 letters
ENTICER7 letters
FAKEIT6 letters
LORELEI7 letters
LURE4 letters
LURER5 letters
MANTRAP7 letters
SEXKITTEN9 letters
SIREN5 letters
WINGIT6 letters