"___ who?!"

SEZ3 lettersrecorded 9 times for this clue

The New York Times, Tuesday, 20 October 2009, set by Gary Cee.

Also in 8 further puzzles in The New York Times, 1998–2007.

DOESNT6 lettersrecorded 4 times for this clue

The New York Times, Saturday, 30 January 2010, set by Mark Diehl.

Also in 3 further puzzles in The New York Times, 2002–2008.

SAYS4 lettersrecorded 3 times for this clue

The New York Times, Tuesday, 28 January 2003, set by Christina Houlihan.

Also in 2 further puzzles in The New York Times, 1996–2000.

ELSE4 lettersrecorded 2 times for this clue

The New York Times, Sunday, 4 July 2010, set by Patrick Blindauer and Tony Orbach — MAKING ENDS MEET.

Also in 1 further puzzle in The New York Times, 2006.

AMI3 lettersrecorded 2 times for this clue

The New York Times, Sunday, 24 January 2010, set by David Kwong and Kevan Choset — ABRIDGED EDITION.

Also in 1 further puzzle in The New York Times, 2008.

DAT3 lettersrecorded 2 times for this clue

The New York Times, Wednesday, 4 May 2011, set by Jeff Chen.

Also in 1 further puzzle in The New York Times, 2007.

ISNT4 lettersrecorded once for this clue

The New York Times, Saturday, 26 February 2005, set by Jim Page.

ISIT4 lettersrecorded once for this clue

The New York Times, Thursday, 20 May 1999, set by Zack Butler.

GUESS5 lettersrecorded once for this clue

The New York Times, Monday, 25 October 2010, set by Jonah Kagan.

CARES5 lettersrecorded once for this clue

The New York Times, Saturday, 16 November 2002, set by Leonard Williams.

THREEYEAROLDS13 lettersrecorded once for this clue

The New York Times, Saturday, 3 May 2003, set by John Scott Marrone.

TIPSOVERAQUARIUM16 lettersrecorded once for this clue

The New York Times, Sunday, 15 April 2007, set by Brendan Emmett Quigley — RUBE GOLDBERG DEVICE.